What does Ellen White write about...

Adventistische Schriften über: "Errors in the essay on Daniel 9: 457 BC, baptism in AD 27, crucifixion in AD 31 and 34"

Answer

I do not have the essay itself in front of me. I can therefore only check the dates mentioned, and no single passage answers all three points at once. The key dates 457 BC, AD 27, AD 31 and AD 34 agree exactly with Ellen White's writings, though with clearly distinct meanings. 457 BC is when the decree took effect in the autumn, AD 27 is the baptism and anointing in the autumn, AD 31 is the crucifixion in the spring, and AD 34 is the end of the 70 weeks. It is an error if the essay places the crucifixion in the year 34 (or 33). It is also an error if it treats 31 and 34 as alternatives for the same event, or if, in calculating, it overlooks the missing year zero. Differing seasons, such as a baptism in the spring of 27, are likewise not supported by Ellen White.

1. Daniel 9 and the Decree of 457 BC

Ellen White sets the beginning of the 70 weeks at the decree of Artaxerxes in Ezra 7. It took effect in the autumn of 457 BC. If an essay gives only "457" without a season, that is imprecise. The calculation to the autumn of AD 27 presupposes autumn as the starting point.

The Completed Decree of 457 BC as the Starting Point

»In the seventh chapter of Ezra is found the decree issued by Artaxerxes, king of Persia, in 457 BC. Three kings brought it, by initiating and completing the decree, to the completeness that the prophecy required to mark the beginning of the 2300 years. … The decree of Artaxerxes went into effect in the autumn of 457 BC. From this date, 483 years extend to the autumn of AD 27.«

Historical Confirmation of the Date 457 BC

»According to Jewish reckoning, the fifth month (Ab) of the seventh regnal year of Artaxerxes ran from July 23 to August 21, 457 BC. After Ezra's arrival in Jerusalem, the king's decree took effect in the autumn of that year.«

This appendix to "The Great Controversy" explains why the autumn of 457 BC, and not another point in the year, is taken as the beginning.

2. The Baptism of Christ around AD 27

The 69 weeks, that is 483 years, extend from the autumn of 457 BC to the autumn of AD 27. At that time Jesus was anointed with the Holy Spirit at His baptism. A common calculation error arises when one simply computes 483 − 457 = 26 and arrives at "AD 26." Since there is no year zero, the correct result is AD 27.

The 69 Weeks End with the Anointing of the Messiah

»The commandment to restore and build Jerusalem, as completed by the decree of Artaxerxes Longimanus, went into effect in the autumn of 457 BC. From this time, four hundred and eighty-three years extend to the autumn of AD 27. According to the prophecy, this period was to reach to the Messiah, the Anointed One. In AD 27, Jesus received the anointing of the Holy Spirit at His baptism and soon afterward began His ministry.«

Calculation across the Turn of the Era without a Year Zero

»From the decree of Artaxerxes, four hundred and fifty-seven years extend to the year AD 1. But of the sixty-nine weeks there still remained twenty-six years (483 − 457 = 26), which ended with the baptism of Christ. Twenty-six years added to the year AD 1 bring us to AD 27, in the autumn of which Christ was baptized.«

This calculation shows how, with correct counting, one arrives at AD 27.

3. Crucifixion in AD 31 or 34

Here lies the most common confusion. According to Ellen White, Christ was crucified "in the midst of the week," that is, in the spring of AD 31, three and a half years after the baptism. The year AD 34, by contrast, is not a crucifixion date. It marks the end of the 70 weeks, with the stoning of Stephen and the turning of the gospel to the Gentiles. If the essay gives 34 (or 33) as the year of the crucifixion, that is wrong according to these sources.

Crucifixion AD 31, End of the 70 Weeks AD 34

»And in the midst of the week he shall cause the sacrifice and the oblation to cease." In AD 31, three and a half years after His baptism, our Lord was crucified. … The seventy weeks, or 490 years, especially allotted to the Jews, ended, as we have seen, in AD 34. At that time the nation sealed its rejection of the gospel by the action of the Jewish Sanhedrin, through the martyrdom of Stephen and the persecution of the followers of Christ.«

Why the Date AD 33 Does Not Hold

»The common biblical chronology, which places the crucifixion in AD 33, rested, according to Dr. Hales, on no earlier authority than that of Roger Bacon in the thirteenth century. … We have thus thirteen credible authorities placing the crucifixion in the spring of AD 31. … If, then, He was crucified in the spring of AD 31, He was baptized and began to preach three and a half years earlier, in the autumn of AD 27.«

Uriah Smith supplements Ellen White with the historical reasoning for why AD 31 and not AD 33 is held as the year of the crucifixion. This is useful in case the essay follows the widespread dating to 33.

Original Sources (English)

Loading...

Stephan Krol

Founder of EGW Vision

Why I built EGW Vision

Hello, I am Stephan Krol. I started this Ellen White website to make the writings of Ellen G. White and the Adventist pioneers easier to access for everyone.

EGW Vision helps you find topics, statements, and quotes faster, especially when many original sources are not yet fully available in your language. The tool searches semantically, groups relevant content by topic, and presents matching results as clearly as possible in your language.

My hope is that this tool supports personal Bible study, strengthens trust in the original sources, and helps more people discover the message of these writings with clarity, depth, and joy.

Telegram Info Kanal

Mein Telegram Kanal (wenig updates)

Zum Projekt
Profilbild von Stephan Krol
EGW
EGW Vision
© Copyright 2026 EGW Vision.